BMW i4 vs Tesla Model 3 Which is the best buy?

The Tesla Model 3 is currently the world’s best-selling electric car. Although the American sedan went on sale in mid-2017; that is, almost five years ago, the truth is that so far it has hardly had any direct rivals within the D segment (medium sedans), a category that has been revitalized with its arrival.

Although it is expected that in the short term numerous general proposals (Hyundai IONIQ 6, Volkswagen ID.7) and premium proposals (Audi A4 e-Tron, Mercedes-Benz EQC Berlina, NIO eT5, XPeng P5…) will join this market niche, at present its main competitors are the newly launched BMW i4 and Polestar 2.

Since the Swedish is still sold in a limited number of countries, the Model 3’s most international rival today is the i4. Both share a similar approach: fastback bodies, a sports set-up, rear and all-wheel drive configurations, sports versions capable of overshadowing the “coconuts” of the thermal sector…

However, the BMW has been conceived from a conventional model (Series 4 Gran Coupé), so it uses a multi-energy platform (CLAR), while the Tesla is based on a specific architecture specially optimized to house the mechanical organs of an electric car. Which alternative is the most interesting?

BMW i4 vs Tesla Model 3: measurements and habitability

At 4.78 meters long, the BMW i4 is slightly longer than its rival, which stands at 4.69 meters. However, this does not affect a higher battle (probably because it is part of a thermal model), since the North American enjoys a wheelbase 1 centimeter higher (2.86 meters for the BMW; 2.87 meters for the Tesla).

BMW i4 vs Tesla Model 3

The width (1.85 meters) and height (1.45 meters in the BMW and 1.44 meters in the Tesla) are practically identical. Based on our previous contacts with both cars, we can say that the habitability in the rear seats is somewhat better in the Model 3 since the i4 is penalized by reduced legroom and a bulky center tunnel.

The tables change if we analyze the trunks since the i4 enjoys a practical gate; In addition, it has better capacity than its rival (470 liters for the BMW, 425 liters for the Tesla). However, we must not lose sight of the fact that the Model 3 has a practical frunk (front trunk) that adds another 117 liters to the whole. If we focus on the quality of finishes and ergonomics, the BMW i4 comes out ahead of its rival; by contrast, the Tesla Model 3 offers a more intuitive infotainment system.

BMW i4 Tesla Model 3
Long 4.78 meters 4.69 meters
Broad 1.85 meters 1.85 meters
Height 1.45 meters 1.44 meters
Battle 2.86 meters 2.87 meters
Trunk 470 liters 117 liters + 425 liters

BMW i4 vs Tesla Model 3: engine, range, and charging

The BMW i4 is available in two versions, eDrive40 and M50. The first model is rear-wheel drive (“single motor”), offers 340 hp (250 kW) of power, can do 0 to 100 km/h in 5.7 seconds, and reaches a top speed of 190 km/h. The second enjoys a total traction system (“dual motor”) and reaches 544 CV (400 kW), which allows it to lower the time to 3.9 seconds and announce a top speed of 225 km/h.

In both cases, the battery has a useful capacity of 80.7 kWh. Due to its lower energy consumption, the eDrive40 ( 590 km WLTP ) approves a greater autonomy than the M50 ( 510 km WLTP ). At the load level, both one and the other are identical, being limited to 11 kW in alternating current and 210 kW in direct current (10-80% in 31 minutes).

BMW i4 vs Tesla Model 3

The Tesla Model 3 range is divided into three variants: the access model RWD (rear-wheel drive, 325 hp, 0-100 km/h in 6.1 seconds, 225 km/h), the intermediate Long Range AWD (all-wheel drive , 351 hp, 0-100 km/h in 4.4 seconds, 233 km/h) and the sporty Performance (all-wheel drive, 480 hp, 0-100 km/h in 3.3 seconds, 261 km/h)

While the Model 3 RWD uses a 58 kWh pack that provides a range of 491 km WLTP, the Long Range AWD ( 602 km WLTP ) and Performance ( 547 km WLTP ) use another 79 kWh. It would be interesting to note that the basic model uses LFP (lithium iron phosphate) cells, a chemical with greater durability, but more sensitivity to low temperatures. While all Model 3s can charge at 11kW on AC, on DC the RWD (170kW) is more limited than its siblings (250kW).

Power Acceleration (0-100 km / h) Maximum speed Battery Autonomy (WLTP) Carga (AC) Charge (DC)
BMW i4 eDrive40 340 CV (250 kW) 5.7 seconds 190 km/h 80,7 kWh 590 km 11 kW 210 kW
BMW i4 M50 544 CV (400 kW) 3.9 seconds 225 km/h 80,7 kWh 510 km 11 kW 210 kW
Tesla Model 3 RWD 325 CV (239 kW) 6.1 seconds 225 km/h 58 kWh 491 km 11 kW 170 kW
Tesla Model 3 Long Range AWD 351 CV (258 kW) 4.4 seconds 233 km/h 79 kWh 602 km 11 kW 250 kW
Tesla Model 3 Performance 480 CV (353 kW) 3.3 seconds 261 km/h 79 kWh 547 km 11 kW 250 kW

BMW i4 vs Tesla Model 3: prices

The Tesla Model 3 is significantly more affordable than the BMW i4, something that is not only because the Californian has an access version because, in equivalent versions (eDrive40 and Long Range, M50 and Performance), the Bavarian is more expensive than its rival despite offering somewhat lower autonomy and performance.

In return, the i4 is much more customizable than the Model 3, with endless color options, upholstery, trim, aesthetic kits, and equipment that allow you to configure a custom unit… as long as we go through the box.

The Tesla is available with five paints (ten in the BMW), two upholstery (fifteen in the BMW), and two-wheel models (six in the BMW), while in the list of extras we only find the Improved Autopilot (3,800 euros) and the Full Self-Driving pack (7,500 euros). This has its counterpoint because some equipment that is optional in the BMW comes standard in the Tesla.

BMW i4 eDrive40 BMW i4 M50 Tesla Model 3 RWD Tesla Model 3 Long Range AWD Tesla Model 3 Performance
Price €60,900 €75,500 €48,360 €54,970 €63,970

BMW i4 vs Tesla Model 3: conclusions

As we have seen, each of these vehicles has its strengths and weaknesses. In favor of the BMW, it should be noted its quality of finishes, its numerous customization options, and its commercial network and technical service extended throughout the national geography; Against this, the Tesla offers somewhat better performance, slightly higher autonomy, and lower prices.

The post BMW i4 vs Tesla Model 3 Which is the best buy? appeared first on Latest Car News.


Latest Car News

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

New KIA e-Niro already has a price in Spain

Image
A few months after its official presentation, KIA opened the order books for the new e-Niro in Spain. The revamped compact SUV, which now sits on the K3 platform already seen in the latest Hyundai Elantra, is slightly longer (6.5 centimeters) than its predecessor and  debuts a completely revamped exterior and interior design . However, mechanically there are not too many changes. The second-generation KIA e-Niro is equipped with a 204 hp (150 kW) and 255 Nm engine coupled to the front axle, thanks to which it can complete the 0 to 100 km/h in 7.8 seconds. Its battery pack will have a capacity of 64.8 kWh, enough to approve a maximum of  463 km WLTP  (its official consumption is 15.9 kWh/100 km), a minimal improvement compared to the 455 km WLTP achieved by its predecessor which tells us that, despite the use of a new platform, the powertrain is likely to be very similar. As for the load, for the moment it has only been revealed that it  will take 43 minutes to go from 10 to 80%  conn
Read more

Peugeot 508 2023: Revealed with new design

Image
Peugeot has introduced the new 508 and station wagon version 508 SW. The design has become modern, as have the engines. We tell you what you need to know. Peugeot unveiled the new 508 and 508 SW. The mid-life facelift brings not only a new look but also new technology. The Peugeot Sport Engineered version has also been revised, and the alternative to the BMW M340i gets a little more power than before. 2023 Peugeot 508 prices and launch date The new Peugeot 508 will be launched in June this year, with deliveries starting shortly thereafter. The exact pricing has not yet been announced, but we expect it to be more expensive than the current model. The 508 in the standard version will probably cost around 47,000 euros, the station wagon is a bit more expensive. Exterior design The Peugeot 508 has always been a great family car, and this facelift brings it up to date for 2023. The most noticeable change can be seen at the front. The grille has been completely revised and now looks muc
Read more

VW thinks price war in China will lead to many bankruptcies

Image
Ralf Brandstätter, CEO of the Volkswagen Group in China , believes that the electric car market is “overheating”, with high investments and aggressive discounts that could threaten the stability of the sector. In particular, he points out that the pressure to which some manufacturers are subjected could lead to their demise. This situation mainly affects younger brands: according to the manager, many new players will urgently have to seek additional capital investment, or else they will go  bankrupt in the short term .  “We are facing a situation where the market is overheating. The consolidation of the playing field is in full swing. Although without making direct mention of Tesla, Brandstätter  is very critical of the price war that has rocked the Chinese market in recent months .  “Currently, there are more than 120 automakers in the [electric vehicle] market, and around 150 new models will be launched by 2023. Intense competition and high battery prices make them face strong econ
Read more